What critics and reviewers have said about Ray Carney's American Vision: The Films of Frank Capra

Click here for best printing of text

The Georgia Review
"An ambitious and eloquent book [that] reads extraordinarily well. Carney speaks with freshness, clarity, and an absence of theoretical claptrap. He produces thoughtful and sometimes exuberant analyses of such Capra perennials as Meet John Doe and Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, as well as It's a Wonderful Life. . . [American Vision is] a book that should advance the reputations of both Frank Capra and Raymond Carney."

Leland Poague, author of Frank Capra in Film Quarterly
"An extraordinary achievement and undertaking.... A true fruition and a powerful defense of the auteurist impulse in film studies."

Film Study
"Offers fresh insights into Capra's career and the characters he created for the screen. Particularly impressive is the author's ability to tie the filmmaker's work to elements in the traditional arts and to Capra's peers in the film industry . . . The skill with which the author develops his thesis provides a model for future studies of this type."

Wilson Library Bulletin
"Carney makes a convincing case for his view of Capra as an 'American dreamer.'... His subtle analyses of individual films consistently reveal new slants even on movies already well covered in film criticism.... Carney opens new widows onto the important achievement of this major American director, and provides a framework for appreciating the depth and artistry of Capra's 'American Vision.'"

Library Journal
"The examples he cites of the strategies the films share with specific paintings by Homer, Eakins, and Sargent support Carney's fresh insights into the stylistics Capra developed and make the reevaluation he urges of the films all the more compelling. Recommended."

"[An] exciting art criticism book . . . so different from the many film criticism texts published in America and Europe."

The Journal of American Studies
"Carney constantly makes revealing and instructive comparisons with novelists and painters to link Capra to the themes and forms of American Romanticism. He advances his thesis further in a closely argued and densely detailed discussion of the individual films, assessing design, lighting, music, cutting, staging and acting styles.... All this is immensely valuable and Carney assembles a persuasive case."

Movie Collector's World
[American Vision] is a challenging, invigorating, and masterful work.... Carney's book allows us not only a greater appreciation of Capra's genius, but a greater understanding of film and what film can accomplish in its efforts to entertain us, challenge us, and, perhaps, inspire us."

Jeanine Basinger, Curator, Wesleyan University Frank Capra Archives and author of the It's a Wonderful Life Book
"The most detailed, intelligent, original, and accurate interpretations of [Capra's] work."

* * *

John Cassavetes on Ray Carney's American Vision
"It is such a pleasure to see energy flow in a positive direction. I share [Ray Carney's] love for Capra...in my estimation the greatest of all American directors, a man who was so beautiful, so forgiving, so democratic, so damned talented, so full of life and energy that his films patrol the imagination of America today. He represents a country that perhaps never was. We see his heavies and they are the mighty, the unbeatable, no longer caring until they are made to care by the innocent persistence of the heroes. The villains continue to be greedy until Capra's people make them realize that there's joy to living.... He is the American dream."

Ray Carney, American Vision: The Films of Frank Capra (Hanover, N.H. University Press of New England, 1996), 88 illustrations, paperback, 510 pages. This book is available directly from the author for $20.

The first interdisciplinary study of America's best-known filmmaker. In this daring and unorthodox study, Ray Carney places the work of Frank Capra in the great tradition of American transcendentalism–along with paintings by Homer, Eakins, Sargent, Hopper and the writings of Emerson, Poe, Hawthorne, and William and Henry James, among others.

Interweaving wide-ranging discussions of American literature, drama, and painting and the work of other filmmakers with detailed analyses of such films as Itís a Wonderful Life, Meet John Doe, and Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, Carney finds in Capraís life and work a classic American struggle for self-expression within the repressive structures of ordinary life. In this larger cultural context, Capra emerges as something far more radical than the social realist he is often taken to be–as a visionary determined to unleash "mysterious, distinctive, personal energies that defy social understandings or control."

American Vision was reprinted in 1996 with a new Preface, outlining recent developments in Capra criticism, and detailing the shortcomings of current Cultural Studies approaches to his work.

* * *

This book is available through Amazon, Barnes and Noble , your local bookseller, or, for a limited time, directly from the author (in discounted and specially autographed editions). See below for information how to order this book directly from the author by money order, check, or credit card.

To obtain a copy directly from the author (please stipulate if you would like an inscription or autograph on the inside front cover), please send $20 (US Postal Money Order only) with your name and address, and the title of the book you are ordering, to the following address. (Domestic US orders only.)

Ray Carney
Special Book Offer
College of Communication
640 Commonwealth Avenue
Boston University
Boston, MA 02215

Credit Card
Now you can buy Ray Carney's works online using Visa or MasterCard.

If you pay by credit card using the PayPal button, please note in the item description or comments section of the order form the exact title of the item or items you are ordering (be specific, since many items have similar titles), as well as any preferences you may have about an autograph or inscription and the name or nickname you would like to have on the inscription.

If you are confused by the PayPal form, or unsure where to enter this information, you may simply make your credit card payment that way, and separately email me (at the address below) any and all information about what item you are ordering, and what inscription or name you would like me to write on it, or any other details about your purchase. I will respond promptly.

The PayPal form has a place for you to indicate the number of items you want (if you want more than one of any item), as well as your mailing address.

If you place your order and send your payment by mail, please include a sheet of paper with the same information on it. I am glad to do custom inscriptions to friends or relatives, as long as you provide all necessary information, either on the PayPal form, in a separate email to me, or by regular mail. (Though I cannot take credit card information by mail; PayPal is the only way I can do that.)

If you want to order other items from other pages, and are using the PayPal button, you may combine several items in one order and have your total payment reflect the total amount, or you may order other items separately when you visit other pages. Since there is no added shipping or handling charge (shipping in the US is free), you will not be penalized for ordering individual items separately in separate orders. It will cost exactly the same either way.

These instructions apply to American shipments only. Individuals from outside the United States should email me and inquire about pricing and shipping costs for international shipments.

Clicking on PayPal opens a separate window in your browser so that this window and the information in it will always be available for you to consult before, during, and after clicking on the PayPal button. After you have completed your PayPal purchase and your order has been placed, you will automatically be returned to this page. If, on the other hand, you go to the PayPal page and decide not to complete your order, you may simply close the PayPal window at any point and this page should still be visible in a window underneath it.

If you have questions, comments, or problems, or if you would like to send me additional information about your order, please feel free to email me at: raycarney@usa.net

Top of Page

© Text Copyright 2003 by Ray Carney. All rights reserved. May not be reprinted without written permission of the author.