Zimmer, M.M., T. Plank. (2006) The role of water in generating Fe-depletion and the calc-alkaline trend. Eos. Trans. AGU, 87(52) Fall Meet. Suppl., Abstract V23C-0636.
Describing a magmatic suite as calc-alkaline (CA) or tholeiitic (TH) is a first order characterization, but existing classification schemes (AFM ternary plots and FeO*/MgO vs. SiO2) may convolute magmatic processes and can result in contradictory classification. The salient feature of TH vs. CA evolution is the extent of Fe enrichment or depletion in the magma. A plot of FeO* vs. MgO provides the most straightforward way to quantify Fe enrichment and to develop models for its origin.
We present a new quantitative classification utilizing the FeO*-MgO plot, the tholeiitic index (THI) = Fe3-5/Fe8 (Fe3-5=average FeO* at 3-5 wt% MgO; Fe8=FeO* at 8 wt% MgO). THI of 1.2 indicates 20% FeO* enrichment from a magma's starting composition at Fe8, while THI of 0.8 indicates 20% depletion in FeO*. A magmatic suite is CA if THI is <1, and TH if THI is >1. Arcs range from 0.6 to 1.1, back arc basins from 1.1-1.3, and MORBs are \ge1.6. This classification allows comparison of magmatic evolution on a global basis, regardless of starting composition, and is useful for quantitative comparison to liquid line of descent models. Hypotheses for generating CA magmas include high water contents, high pressure of crystallization, high oxygen fugacity, and high Mg#; andesitic starting compositions.
In order to test the control of H2O, we compare the THI to average magmatic water contents from undegassed melt inclusions and glasses (S>1000 ppm or CO2>50 ppm) from twenty-eight arc volcanoes and back arc basins, including new water contents from seven Aleutian volcanoes. The resulting negative correlation (R2=0.8) between water concentration and THI (with end-members at 0.8 wt% H2O, THI =1.3 and 6.1 wt% H2O, THI = 0.6) suggests water plays a fundamental role in generating the CA fractionation trend. MORB data plot off the trend at a higher THI, possibly related to lower oxygen fugacity during melting and/or crystallization. Models using the pMelts program are consistent with experimentally- and observationally-demonstrated effects of water on suppression of plagioclase and early formation of oxides relative to silicates during magma fractionation, and the resulting FeO* depletion with respect to decreasing MgO.