Zimmer, M.M., T. Plank, E.H. Hauri, C. Nye, J. Faust Larsen, P.B. Kelemen (2004) Volatile contents in mafic magmas from two Aleutian volcanoes: Augustine and Makushin. Eos. Trans. AGU, 85(47) Fall Meet. Suppl., Abstract V34A-01.
There are several competing theories for the origin of tholeiitic (TH) vs. calc-alkaline (CA) fractionation trends in arc magmas. One relates to water (TH-dry magma, CA-wet magma), another to pressure (TH-low pressure crystallization, CA-high pressure), and a third to primary magma composition (TH-low Si/Fe#, CA-hi Si/F\#). These theories have been difficult to test without quantitative measures of the water contents and pressures of crystallization of arc magmas.
We are in the process of studying several Aleutian arc tephra suites (phenocrysts and melt inclusions) with the aim of obtaining volatile element concentrations (by SIMS), major and trace element concentrations and thermobarometric data (by EMP and laser-ICPMS). We report preliminary results on olivine-hosted melt inclusions from Augustine and Makushin volcanoes that support the role of water in calc-alkaline fractionation. Basaltic melt inclusions from Augustine, a low-K2O, calc-alkaline volcano, are hosted in Fo80-82 olivine. The inclusions yield high water contents, up to 5 wt%, and contain 60-90 ppm CO2, 3000-4500 ppm S, and 3000-6000 ppm Cl. Inclusions record vapor-saturation pressures near 2 kbar. Cl/K2O ratios in Augustine inclusions (ave. 1.9) are among the highest documented in an arc setting, and likely record a Cl- and H2O- rich fluid from the subducting plate. High water contents in Augustine primary melts may have contributed to the strong calc-alkaline trend observed at this volcano. Basaltic melt inclusions from Pakushin, a medium-K2O, tholeiitic cone on the flanks of Makushin volcano, are hosted in Fo80-86 olivine. These inclusions have low water contents (< 0.15 wt%) and low CO2 contents (< 125 ppm), and record shallow vapor saturation pressures (< 300 bars). The high sulfur (2000-4000 ppm) and Cl (> 2000 ppm) in Pakushin melt inclusions, however, indicate that degassing was minimal.
The low water contents and low vapor saturation pressures recorded in Pakushin melt inclusions are consistent with development of its tholeiitic trend, but we cannot distinguish whether the low water contents at Pakushin reflect a difference in the primary magma, or in crustal stresses that favor low pressure fractionation and degassing. These questions will be addressed with further work on the trace element contents of the melt inclusions and on phenocryst-melt geobarometers.