|
Mikhail Pyatigorsky
ResearchMexican-Americans
in US Schools
(Job
Market Paper) - PDF This
paper analyzes the impact of 1st
and 2nd generation immigrants from Mexico, the largest immigrant
group in the US, on both native schoolchildren and the
Mexican-Americans
themselves. My contributions to the literature are twofold.
First, I
use self-reported friendship data to
show that Mexican-Americans have strongly assortative networks that
span grade
levels. A number of studies have used intra-school grade-level
variations in peer characteristics to identify peer effects, relying on
the assumption that classmates are the relevant peer group. My findings
demonstrate that, in the case of Mexican-American adolescents, this
assumption is invalid. Second, contrary to what we might expect given
previous
results on immigration, I find little evidence of between- or
within-group
negative effects of Mexican-American students. My results suggest that
having
Mexican-American classmates is not significantly correlated with
natives’
college attendance, or with variables such as engagement in risky
behavior,
delinquency, or sexual activity. There is also no statistically
significant
effect of having Mexican-American friends on Mexican-Americans’ own
long-term
academic outcomes.
This paper analyzes gender peer effects among junior and high school students. The sample is drawn from a large, nationally representative, longitudinal study of adolescents, with detailed individual and school information. Variation in the proportion of girls across grade levels within a school provides the identification, while school selection is controlled with fixed effects. The availability of short and long term academic indicators, as well as extensive data on attitudes towards school and school involvement, delinquency, friendships, and sexual activity provides a unique look at the ways in which adolescent girls and boys affect each other. My results suggest that high school girls who have more female classmates are significantly and substantially more likely to graduate. However, there is no significant correlation between sex ratios and high school completion among boys; or grades, enrollment in advanced courses, or college attendance of boys or girls. On the other hand, I do find significant behavioral effects, whose direction is consistent with literature on (a) marriage markets and (b) pubertal development. Namely, the proportion of girls in a school-grade is positively correlated with being sexually active among girls and with being sexually aware among younger boys. Having more female classmates is also correlated with more positive attitudes towards school but, at the same time, greater likelihood of delinquent, and potentially dangerous, behaviors among boys.
What is the overall impact of immigrants in American schools? Do they affect the quality of instruction, the attitude of native students towards school, the propensity to “misbehave”? Does this matter for long-term outcomes, such as academic performance and health indicators after high school? Building upon previous work with the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health, I analyze the degree to which immigrant peer effects vary according to the observable characteristics of immigrant students, such as country of origin and level of acculturation. This research is underway. The goal is to understand the specific mechanisms through which immigration impacts the native population. |